Frostbearer is 4 star catalyst with ATK substats. You can forge this catalyst in your friendly local blacksmith, require 1x Northlander catalyst billet, 50x crystal
Tulaytullahs Remembrance is 5 star catalyst with CRIT DMG substats. Obtainable from limited weapon banner, and tailor made for Scaramouche or The Wanderer. A bell
Blackcliff Agate is 4 star catalyst with CRIT DMG substats. This catalyst is part of Blackcliff weapon series, obtainable from Paimon Bargain Shop for 24